Sarah Silverman Says Pamela Anderson ‘Does Not Care for Me’ After 2005 Roast

Sarah Silverman has many fans, but she may not count Pamela Anderson among them.

During Silverman’s recent appearance on SiriusXM’s Andy Cohen Live to discuss her new Netflix special, the comedian and actress, 54, told host Andy Cohen that Anderson appeared upset with her over jokes she told at Comedy Central’s 2005 Roast of Pamela Anderson when they crossed paths at a Hollywood event recently.

Cohen, 56, brought up Anderson while the two discussed Silverman’s career and noted that she appeared in a 2002 episode of Anderson’s action-comedy series V.I.P.

“I will tell you something about Pam Anderson, who I think does not care for me, [which] I was surprised by,” Silverman said, after stating that she enjoyed her one-episode run on V.I.P. The comedian explained that she attended “a big fancy Hollywood gala that they have every year” last year as her friend Sacha Baron Cohen’s date following his April 2024 divorce from Isla Fisher.

“So I went, and she was there, and of course he’s got that connection from Borat with her and I had roasted her, and I was on that show, V.I.P.,” Silverman said of Anderson. Silverman added that Cohen offered to introduce Silverman to Anderson, but when the introduction happened, Anderson allegedly balked at a friendly greeting. “She looks at me and she goes, ‘Oh yeah. You told horrible jokes about me on my roast,’ and then she turned around and left and I was like, my heart [is broken],” Silverman said.

A representative for Anderson did not immediately respond to PEOPLE’s request for comment.

Silverman appeared at Comedy Central’s 2005 Roast of Pamela Anderson alongside her ex-boyfriend Jimmy Kimmel, who hosted the occasion, as well as Courtney Love, Adam Carolla, the late Bea Arthur, Tommy Lee, Jeff Ross and Andy Dick, among other comedians. 

Never miss a story — sign up for PEOPLE’s free daily newsletter to stay up-to-date on the best of what PEOPLE has to offer​​, from celebrity news to compelling human interest stories.

A video Comedy Central posted to YouTube that features much of Silverman’s set at the 2005 roast shows her poking fun at Anderson’s model-esque looks and her and Lee’s infamous 1990s sex tape.

“You know a lot of people say ‘Oh, Pam Anderson wouldn’t be anyone without her tits,’ ” Silverman said at one point during the roast. “And that’s just not true. It’s not true. She’d be Paris Hilton.”

Moments from Anderson’s roast have resurfaced before: in 2018, renewed attention was placed on footage of comedian Andy Dick groping Anderson’s breasts during the special after he was charged with sexual battery for groping a woman in Los Angeles.